Cheesy Eddie's is a trusted bakery and cake shop in Rochester, NY, where handcrafted baked goods, rich flavors, and warm hospitality come together in every visit.
With a 4.90-star rating from 739 reviews, this Rochester bakery and cake shop has earned a strong reputation for quality, consistency, and a welcoming atmosphere that keeps customers coming back.
From fresh-baked treats made with carefully selected ingredients to specialty cakes and classic favorites, Cheesy Eddie's brings the comfort, celebration, and satisfaction that only a top-rated bakery in Rochester, NY can deliver.
Whether you are planning a birthday, celebrating a milestone, or simply craving something delicious, this bakery and cake shop in Rochester, NY offers memorable flavors, friendly service, and a customer experience designed to feel easy, enjoyable, and rewarding.
Convenient amenities such as a wheelchair-accessible car park and wheelchair-accessible entrance help make every visit smooth and inclusive. To discover why so many locals choose Cheesy Eddie's for bakery and cake shop favorites in Rochester, NY, visit today and experience the difference of a highly rated neighborhood bakery built on flavor, care, and community.
Popular Items
Frequently ordered and highly recommended items at Cheesy Eddie's
Our Story
Welcome to a place where great food meets warm hospitality. We believe dining is more than just a meal - it's an experience to be savored and shared.
Our kitchen is dedicated to creating dishes that bring people together, using recipes that honor tradition while embracing innovation.
Photos
A glimpse of our restaurant experience
Food & Drinks
Hear from our valued guests
We used Cheesy Eddies for our wedding cake. It came out beautifully and the carrot cake tasted amazing. It was a seamless process.
Staff is always friendly and helpful. Amazing cheesecakes and carrot cakes. Haven't found any that can compare in flavors yet....
Very good cheesecake, nice and dense and there are so many flavors to choose from! We picked the coconut cream, carrot cake, blueberry, peanut butter cup, and red velvet cheese cake along with a few of their minis. They are all VERY good but the coconut cream (red velvet close second) is my favorite and my husband liked the carrot cake cheese cake best. He also had the carrot cake it's self which he said was delicious. I had the raspberry cupcake which is a dense vanilla cake with raspberry cheesecake center and amazing raspberry butter cream icing, so good! We will be stopping next time we are in Rochester to try them other flavors as nothing we picked was a disappointment and their staff is very friendly!
As many should know - this is the best place to get a carrot cake. It's so good. I ordered online for the first time and mistaking went to the Rochester location to pick it up (not knowing online ordering goes to Henrietta location). The staff quickly resolved my mistake by pulling a carrot cake from the fridge and packaging that up for me so I didn't have to go all the way to Henrietta. I am very thankful for this excellent service and am very appreciative.
Absolutely amazing bakery! I'd been meaning to stop by myself after receiving some of the small cheesecakes as a gift and they did not disappoint! The staff is extremely friendly, and it seems like everyone knows each other there which is so sweet. Their cheesecakes are to die for, they're not overly sweet. The carrot cakes as well stayed moist and delicious. Absolutely will be going here for birthday needs 💜
I live in Buffalo and always come across this place on the internet when searching for cheesecake. I am just never in the area. Finally the day before Thanksgiving i happen to be in Batavia and decided I was also finally going to make the trip and I am so glad I did. The staff was so nice. I went to the Jeffeeson rd location. I grabbed a few slices of cheesecake. A slice of carrot cake. Also a few cupcakes. Keep in mind all of this is mainly for my kids. I also grabbed a brownie. The gentlemen gave me a cookie sandwich to try. Let's just say everything was delicious. I am so glad I made the trip. And I will definitely be back.
Cheesy Eddie’s has the best desserts in Rochester by far. Their carrot cake is to die for and their cheesecakes come in so many delicious flavors. The staff is always friendly, helpful, and genuinely so nice. They are also incredibly careful with allergies, so I always feel safe enjoying their desserts. This place is a must if you love great desserts!
Best cheesecake I had in a very long time!! It reminded me of the German cheesecake taste. I would definitely recommend this place. The service was fantastic, the nice lady even added raspberries to my cheesecake and made it a swirl. Very delicious 🤤 we also bought some carrot cake and chocolate and both were fabulous. Thank you for a great experience
We used Cheesy Eddie's for our wedding desserts and our guests LOVED IT!! We chose a variety of minis from the menu and every single one was a hit (especially the mini carrot cake cupcakes). Thank you Cheesy Eddie's!!
Oh my Dayz! Why did we leave it so late to visit this place?! For me it’s one of THE BEST family run bakeries I have been to. The interior is cosy, warm and inviting. There is a small seating area for those who can’t wait to get home! Due to dietary restrictions we were shown the items that were out of bounds for us. Then came the impossible task of choosing what to buy. We finally ordered the Carrot Cake slice and the Original Cheesecake. The Carrot Cake had a warm, aromatic flavour, not overly sweet and was a delight to eat. I literally annihilated it. My partner enjoyed his Original Cheesecake so much so that he bought a whole one to go. The Oreo Explosion looked too good to pass so I’ll be digging into that later on today. One thing I have learnt about myself is that I have zero self constraint and my eyes are greedier than my stomach. But I’m blaming Cheesy Eddies for that! Definitely give this place a try. It’s awesome.
Common questions about Cheesy Eddie's
Cheesy Eddie's is located at 602 South Ave, Rochester, NY 14620, United States, Rochester, NY, United States.
You can reach Cheesy Eddie's by calling +1 585-473-1300.
Cheesy Eddie's has a rating of 4.9 out of 5 based on 739 customer reviews.
Cheesy Eddie's features the following accessibility: Wheelchair-accessible car park, Wheelchair-accessible entrance.
Cheesy Eddie's features the following service options: Delivery, In-store pick-up, In-store shopping, On-site services, Takeaway.
Cheesy Eddie's features the following offerings: Coffee.
Cheesy Eddie's features the following planning: Quick visit.
Cheesy Eddie's features the following payments: Credit cards, Debit cards, NFC mobile payments.
Cheesy Eddie's features the following parking: Free street parking.
Business Features
We look forward to welcoming you. Make a reservation or stop by - walk-ins welcome!
Request a table and we'll confirm your booking shortly.
